Independent picks for detailing your own car. We stock nothing, so we have nothing to move.
01
Polishers & correction
Adam's Swirl Killer vs Griot's Garage G9
A 12mm throw against a 9mm throw with a published 1000W motor behind it. One is faster across a hood; the other is the one you can hand to someone else.
Featured here: the Griot's Garage G9 Random Orbital Polisher.
How this is funded: we earn an Amazon commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. We sell nothing and stock nothing, so a pick is never a product we are trying to move. Prices are pulled live from Amazon and were last checked November 19, 2026; where we cannot verify a price we say so rather than print an old one. Full disclosure.
Research-basedPicked from published manufacturer specifications and the consistent pattern across verified-purchase owner reports. Every product here scores 8.4 or better on our rubric.How we pick
Top pickGriot's Garage
Griot's Garage G9 Random Orbital Polisher
A 9mm throw and a 1000W motor put the G9 exactly where most home detailers should be: fast enough to finish a car in an afternoon, short enough in the throw to stay predictable near badges and body lines.
Our score9.4Best for: the default answer for a first serious machine
The Griot's Garage G9 is the better buy for almost everyone, because it is the only one of the two whose maker publishes a motor figure — 1000 W — and because the warranty behind it is a lifetime warranty. Adam's 12mm Swirl Killer is the right choice in one specific case: you already own a short-throw machine, you have run out of patience with how long a hood takes, and you want more speed without going to a 15mm machine.
02
What each maker actually publishes
This comparison is unusually clean, because both machines are free-spinning random orbitals of roughly the same size and the decision comes down to two published numbers rather than to feel. Throw is how far the pad's center travels in each orbit, and it sets how much work the machine does per pass. Wattage is how well the motor holds that throw when you lean on a cutting pad.
Griot's publishes both. Adam's publishes the throw and does not publish a wattage figure we could verify, which is the single most important thing to know before comparing these two on a spec sheet — one column below is a blank rather than a number, and we have left it blank.
Published figures only. A blank is a figure the maker does not publish, not an estimate.
Adam's Swirl Killer 12mm
Griot's Garage G9
Published throw
12 mm
9 mm
Published motor
Not published
1000 W
Published backing plate
Not published
5 in
Speed control
Variable
Variable, 6 positions
In the box
Tool
Tool
Warranty
Adam's standard support
Lifetime, per Griot's Garage
Pad compatibility
5 in plate class
5 in plate, 5.5 in pads
03
The two machines, plus the one most people should actually buy
The G9 and the Swirl Killer side by side, with the G8 included because it is the honest third answer for anyone who has not corrected paint before. Prices are live from Amazon.
Griot's GarageOutstandingSpec-verified
Griot's Garage G9 Random Orbital Polisher
Best for: The default answer for a first serious machine
A 9mm throw and a 1000W motor put the G9 exactly where most home detailers should be: fast enough to finish a car in an afternoon, short enough in the throw to stay predictable near badges and body lines. It is the machine we would buy if we were buying one machine.
Correction speed
Strong
Control
Exceptional
Ergonomics
Good
Build
Exceptional
Value
Strong
Why we picked it
9mm throw is the best general-purpose compromise on the market
1000W does not bog down under pressure on a cutting pad
Griot's lifetime warranty is the strongest in the category
Takes the same 5 in plate and 5.5 in pads as everything else
Good to know. Heavier than the G8, which shows on doors and quarters
12mm sits deliberately between the two established throws, and in practice it behaves much closer to a 15mm machine than a 9mm one — faster across a panel, and wanting more attention near an edge. A reasonable pick if you have used a short-throw machine and want more speed.
Correction speed
Strong
Control
Strong
Ergonomics
Strong
Build
Strong
Value
Good
Why we picked it
12mm throw is a genuine step up in speed from 8 to 9mm
Better balanced than most machines near this price
Adam's support and parts availability are good
Good to know. The in-between throw suits a second machine, not a first
The G8 is the G9's shorter, lighter sibling, and for a lot of people it is the better buy. An 8mm throw is slower across a hood and considerably more forgiving within an inch of an edge, which is exactly where beginners do damage.
Correction speed
Good
Control
Exceptional
Ergonomics
Strong
Build
Exceptional
Value
Strong
Why we picked it
Lighter than the G9 and easier to hold against a door for an hour
8mm throw is the most forgiving option near edges and badges
Same lifetime warranty as the rest of the Griot's line
Good to know. Priced close enough to the G9 that the decision is genuinely about throw
Going from 9 mm to 12 mm is a real difference, and it is not a subtle one on a large flat panel. More throw means the pad covers more area per orbit, so a hood that takes four passes on a 9mm machine takes closer to three. Over a whole car that compounds into a meaningfully shorter afternoon.
The cost is predictability. A longer throw carries more energy to the edge of the pad, and the edge of the pad is what finds badges, body lines and the raised lip around a headlight. Nobody burns through paint in the middle of a door; they do it within an inch of something. A 9mm machine gives you more margin there, which is why the best dual action polishers still ranks the 9mm class first for a general-purpose buy.
12 mm behaves closer to 15 mm than to 9 mm
This is the part that surprises people. The in-between throw sounds like a compromise that splits the difference, and in practice it does not: the Swirl Killer feels much more like a long-throw machine than a short-throw one. That makes it a poor first polisher — it is neither the most forgiving option nor the fastest — and a sensible second one, where you already know how the pad behaves near an edge.
05
The motor figure is the one Adam's leaves blank
A polisher that slows under pad pressure stops cutting at exactly the moment you want it to cut, and you compensate by pressing harder, which slows it further. The published 1000 W behind the G9 is the specific reason it does not do that on a cutting pad.
Adam's does not publish a comparable figure. That is not evidence the Swirl Killer has a weak motor — owner reports do not describe one — but it does mean the comparison cannot be made on published data, and we are not going to invent a number to fill the cell. If motor output under load is the thing you care most about, the machine with a published figure is the machine you can actually check.
06
Warranty is the quiet tiebreaker
Griot's lifetime warranty is the strongest in this category, and a polisher is a tool with brushes, bearings and a switch — things that wear out on a schedule rather than failing randomly. Over a decade of ownership that warranty is worth more than 3 mm of throw.
Adam's support is genuinely good and their parts availability is better than most, so this is not a strike against them so much as an unusually strong card in Griot's hand. It is the reason the ranking above puts the G9 first even though the Swirl Killer is the faster machine on paper.
07
Which one to buy
You have never corrected paint. Neither — buy the G8. An 8mm throw is the most forgiving place to learn, and learning is the expensive part.
You want one machine for the next ten years. The G9. Published motor, published plate size, lifetime warranty.
You already own an 8 or 9mm machine and want speed. The Swirl Killer 12mm, or skip straight to 15mm — RUPES vs Adam's is that decision.
You want pads and liquids in the same box. Neither. Look at the kit in Griot's vs Chemical Guys.
Most of your work is spot repairs on tight panels. The shorter throw wins. More throw is a disadvantage on a mirror cap.
08
What matters more than this choice
Both of these machines will correct paint competently, and the gap between them is smaller than the gap between a good pad and a bad one. The best polishing pads and what size polishing pad change results more than this page does, and how many polishing pads do I need is the question that actually determines whether your second panel looks like your first.
Technique matters more again. How to use a dual action polisher has the pass-by-pass method, and paint correction steps covers the decontamination that has to happen first — polishing a contaminated panel grinds the contamination into it, whichever machine is doing the grinding.
09
Our recommendation
Buy this one
Griot's Garage G9 Random Orbital Polisher
A 9mm throw and a 1000W motor put the G9 exactly where most home detailers should be: fast enough to finish a car in an afternoon, short enough in the throw to stay predictable near badges and body lines.
12mm sits deliberately between the two established throws, and in practice it behaves much closer to a 15mm machine than a 9mm one — faster across a panel, and wanting more attention near an edge.
Is the Adam's Swirl Killer better than the Griot's G9?
It is faster on large flat panels, because 12mm of throw covers more area per orbit than 9mm. The G9 is the better overall buy: Griot's publishes a 1000W motor figure and a 5 in plate size, backs the machine with a lifetime warranty, and the shorter throw is more forgiving near badges and body lines.
What throw does the Adam's Swirl Killer have?
The machine in this comparison is the 12mm Swirl Killer, per Adam's own product documentation. That sits deliberately between the 8 to 9mm short-throw class and the 15mm long-throw class, and in use it behaves closer to the 15mm machines.
Is 12mm throw better than 9mm?
Faster, not better. More throw removes defects in fewer passes, which saves real time on a hood or a roof. It also carries more energy to the pad edge, which is where damage happens — near badges, body lines and headlight lips. For a first machine, 9mm or less is the safer geometry.
How much power does the Adam's Swirl Killer have?
Adam's does not publish a wattage figure we could verify, so this page leaves that cell blank rather than estimating it. Griot's publishes 1000W for the G9. If motor output under pad load is your deciding factor, the G9 is the one you can check.
Do either of these polishers come with pads?
No. Both are sold as bare tools in the listings here, so the real outlay is the machine plus pads plus at least a compound and a finishing polish. A complete-kit option is covered in Griot's vs Chemical Guys.
Which polisher should a beginner buy?
Neither of these two, in most cases. The Griot's G8 at 8mm is the most forgiving of the three machines on this page and the cheapest way to learn without marring an edge. Step up to a 9mm or 12mm machine once the technique is automatic.
11
Sources
Every published figure on this page traces to one of these. Where a manufacturer does not publish a number, the page says so rather than estimating it.
Last reviewed October 17, 2026. Think a figure here is wrong? Tell us at contact@detailingandwax.com and we will check it, fix it and date the correction — see our editorial policy.